S Corporation vs. Partnership: Rules, Benefits & Drawbacks

Written by Tessa Kelly | Sep 10, 2025 6:00:00 PM

Choosing the right structure for your business can have a major impact on taxes, liability, flexibility, and compliance. Here's a clear comparison between S Corporations (S Corps) and Partnerships, with guidance from IRS and government sources to keep everything accurate.

What Are They — Defined

S Corporation (S Corp)

A corporation that elects pass-through taxation under Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code. Profits, losses, deductions, and credits are reported on shareholders' individual tax returns — avoiding corporate double taxation.

Partnership

A business structure where two or more people share ownership. It’s a "flow-through" entity: the partnership itself doesn’t pay taxes—partners do, based on their distributive share under Subchapter K.

Tax Treatment & Self-Employment Tax

S Corp

Avoids double taxation. Income passes directly to shareholders' returns.

Shareholders who work in the business must receive reasonable compensation (W-2 wages), which are subject to payroll taxes. Remaining profits may be distributed as dividends not subject to self-employment tax.

Partnership

Income passes through to partners’ personal returns via Schedule K‑1.

Partners are considered self-employed and pay self-employment tax on their entire distributive share—not just salary.

Flexibility & Basis Treatment

S Corp

Income and losses are allocated strictly based on share ownership — no flexibility.

Shareholders cannot include entity-level debt in their tax basis.

Partnership

Offers flexibility in allocating income, losses, and distributions, as long as allocations reflect economic reality.

Partners can increase basis using entity-level debt and capital contributions — beneficial for deductible losses.

Liability & Credibility

S Corp

Provides limited liability protection to all shareholders — their personal assets are generally safe from business liabilities.

Often seen as more credible by customers, vendors, and investors.

Partnership

General partners face unlimited personal liability. Limited partners have protection only if they don’t manage the business.

Less formal structure may signal less corporate legitimacy to external parties.

Formation, Compliance & Ownership Limits

S Corp

Requires filing Articles of Incorporation, election via IRS Form 2553, and adherence to corporate formalities like annual meetings and minutes.

Stricter ownership rules: up to 100 shareholders, who must be U.S. individuals or certain eligible entities. Only one class of stock permitted.

Partnership

Quicker and simpler to form. Often, no formal state filing is needed—though a partnership agreement is highly recommended.

Ownership changes are more flexible and agile.

summary Table

Feature S Corporation Partnership
Tax Structure

Pass-through; requires reasonable W‑2 wages

Fully pass-through; all earnings subject to self-emp. tax

Flexibility

Rigid allocations (based on shares)

Flexible allocative structure

Liability

Limited liability for all shareholders

General partners exposed; limited partners protected

Formation

Formal, higher compliance burden

Informal, low setup burden

Ownership Rules

Max. 100 shareholders; U.S. persons; one class of stock

Few restrictions — high flexibility

 

When to Consider Each

Choose an S Corp if you:.

Want liability protection and corporate credibility.

Are seeking payroll tax savings via distributions.

Can handle formalities like payroll, meetings, and limits on ownership.

Choose a Partnership if you:

Need flexibility in profit/loss distribution.

Want to use entity debt to enhance basis for losses.

Prefer a simpler structure with lower compliance.

Final THoughts

Choosing between an S Corporation and a Partnership isn’t a one-size-fits-all decision. Each structure comes with unique rules, tax implications, and compliance requirements. While S Corps often provide stronger liability protection and potential payroll tax savings, Partnerships offer greater flexibility in how income and losses are allocated.

The right choice depends on your business goals, industry, ownership structure, and long-term strategy.

👉 Ready to determine which structure is best for your business? Our team at Certus can walk you through the details, highlight the benefits and drawbacks for your specific situation, and help you make the most informed decision possible.

Schedule Your Consultation Here!